About the Recipe
You know that feeling when it’s midnight and you’re already saying “okay but this is the last one” for the third time? That’s the moment for Cliffhanger Cream Soda. It’s creamy and nostalgic but with a little spice to keep you awake. I love it with a thriller series — something that keeps me on edge but in a cozy way.
Ingredients
1 oz dark spiced rum (or splash of cold brew for mocktail)
½ oz vanilla syrup
1 oz half & half (or oat milk)
3 oz club soda or sparkling mineral water
Dash of cinnamon or nutmeg
Ice
Instructions
Step 1
In a glass with ice, mix rum (or alt), vanilla syrup, and milk.
Step 2
Stir until smooth.
Step 3
Top with club soda and a pinch of cinnamon.
Tips
Zero-proof: Use cold brew instead of rum, or a non-alcoholic spirit with baking spice notes.
Flavor swap: Add almond extract or orange zest for a twist.
Pair with: The OA, Dark, or literally anything with a timeline you need to explain afterward.
Make it cozy: Use warm milk instead and skip the soda for a steamier version.
Serving Tips
Glass: Highball or mason jar
Garnish: Cinnamon stick or a tiny cookie on the side
Vibe: Dim lights, text thread open with your “omg did you just see that?” friend